Report Gap Analysis: National Guidelines

30 05 2011

The second major gap in the Report is the need for national school library guidelines. The committee has left this out entirely.

Standards/benchmarks/guidelines were asked for in many submissions, but are totally ignored in the report. In fact, reference to our current professional guidelines is grossly inaccurate!  The first gross error I have found in the Report!!

5.11 ESA publishes the current standards document for Australian school libraries, Learning for the Future: Developing Information Services in Australian SchoolsThe document is predominantly concerned with the implementation and role of ICT in school learning environments (my emphasis) (p. 96).

This is not in ESA’s sub.  It’s a statement by whoever wrote the report!!

Principals, teachers, and parents, in addition to teacher librarians and across sectors asked for national guidelines in their submissions.

The Tasmanian teachers’ union (AEU)  recommended   “That school library benchmarks be established to reflect national standards for services and program delivery and that schools be resourced to these levels” (sub 122).

Brisbane Catholic Education called on the federal government to  “develop national standards related to the provision of qualified teacher librarians in schools” (sub 275).

SLAV recommended “that support be given to the development of benchmarks and standards for the staffing of school libraries appropriate to the objectives of the Australian Curriculum and similar innovative curriculum frameworks documents” (sub 114).

The Australian Council of State School Organizations (parents) “endorses the development and regular revision of a statement of minimum standards and objectives for library resource facilities and services in government schools” (sub 326).

Australian Primary Principals Association recommended “The Inquiry should support the development of nationally-agreed guidelines for the adequacy of school libraries. These guidelines should include criteria for the level and kinds of resources needed in libraries, budget and staffing requirements, the roles libraries can play in schools and the levels and kinds of support needed by school libraries from external sources. The Commonwealth Government should seek the support of state and territory agencies and sector authorities for the development and endorsement of these guidelines” (sub 386).

The Australian School Library Association (ASLA) told the committee “that a motherhood statement at the Commonwealth level would be useful because it would flow through to the Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations (DEEWR) and help set the direction, providing a framework for the deployment of appropriate resources and funding to schools” (Report, p.35).

National guidelines would also inform groups such as the Teaching for the Digital Age Advisory Group, Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership (AISTL), MYCEECDYA, and the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA), as well as other education authorities and sectors.

The Report has put the question of national school library standards in the too hard basket.







2 responses

31 05 2011
Brenda Carter

In my opinion this was one of the most important outcomes I was hoping to see from the Report. It’s nice to receive encouraging feedback but that is just hot air if it doesn’t result in standards for staffing and budgets. Hopefully the Report will lead to ongoing dialogue which results in more concrete opportunities and benefits for teacher librarians.

31 05 2011

Encourage that dialogue at every opportunity, Brenda. Through letters to editors, communication with parents, even getting on the phone to your local federal member. It’s their staffer you will talk to and they will take down what you are saying and make sure the MP gets the message. Time to write to Peter Garrett also. I feel a sample letter coming on 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: